Reddit Post Template

Roast My Landing Page: Reddit Template for Website Feedback

Use a Reddit feedback request template to ask for specific landing-page observations, while respecting community rules and recording what to test next.

Defines a small, concrete review task.
Offers a no-link or screenshot option when links are restricted.
Turns observations into follow-up tests instead of arguments.

Website feedback templates

Roast my landing page / project

Best for design, marketing, and startup subreddits that allow feedback requests.

We just launched [project] to help [audience] do [task], and we need honest website feedback before we spend more time on the page.
We are too close to the product. Our core claim is [value prop], but we are not sure if it makes sense to someone seeing it for the first time.
Specifically looking for feedback on: - Does the headline explain what we do in 5 seconds? - What feels confusing, weak, or untrustworthy? - What objection would stop you from trying it?
Link: [URL]
Do not hold back. We want the harsh truth, especially on messaging, positioning, and trust.
Use this in subreddits that allow feedback requests.You must actually accept the harsh feedback gracefully in the comments.If links are restricted, ask whether a screenshot or text-only description is acceptable.

Website feedback templates

Complete website feedback example

Use this when you want a full ready-to-post draft instead of a bare template.

Roast my landing page. I need honest website feedback before we run more traffic to it.
We built [project] for [audience] who need to [core job]. The homepage says [headline], but I am not sure a first-time visitor would understand that in 5 seconds.
If you have 2 minutes, I would love feedback on: - headline clarity - trust / credibility - pricing confusion - what would stop you from signing up
Here is the page: [URL]
No need to be polite. If the messaging is vague or the page feels sketchy, say it directly. I would rather hear it here than after paying for ads.
This version makes the review task explicit.List only a few dimensions so the request is answerable.Thank people and record disagreements instead of arguing for the current design.

How to get website feedback on Reddit

Website feedback templates

A feedback request works when the community allows it and the review task is specific. Ask about headline clarity, trust, objections, pricing confusion, or the first impression, then record observations and competing explanations. Feedback is evidence for another test, not a guarantee that one comment will improve conversion.

Jump to product

Need more than static copy?

Use the template page as the entry point, then move into subreddit discovery, timing, and safer execution paths.

Customization

How to customize

Direct their focus

Give them 2 to 4 specific areas to critique such as headline clarity, pricing, trust, or mobile UX so the website feedback is useful.

Ask the 5-second question

Invite readers to say what they think the page does after a quick glance. This surfaces messaging problems fast.

Show vulnerability

Admit that you might be wrong or too close to the product. That humility is what unlocks honest feedback.

How to use

How to get website feedback on Reddit

1

Find a subreddit that welcomes critique

Use subreddits or recurring feedback threads where website feedback is explicitly allowed. The same post lands very differently in a general discussion sub.

2

Set the review criteria

Ask for specific feedback on headline clarity, credibility, trust, pricing, friction, or the main objection that stops someone from trying the product.

3

Offer an allowed format

Check whether the community permits links. If not, use a screenshot, excerpt, or text-only description only when that format is allowed.

4

Take the punches gracefully

Thank every person who comments, especially the harsh ones. Never argue or get defensive if you want useful website feedback.

Examples

Bad vs Better

Avoid

Check out my new site! Let me know what you think. [Link]

Better

I've stared at this landing page for 40 hours and I've lost all perspective. Does the headline actually make sense, or is it just marketing jargon? Roast my messaging: [Link]

The better version gives a specific task and sets a humble tone.

Mistakes

Common mistakes

Arguing with feedback

If someone says your site is confusing, it's confusing to them. Don't argue; fix it.

Posting in the wrong sub

Don't post a 'roast me' in a general discussion sub unless they have a specific flair for it.

Related reads

Further reading

FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

Will this hurt my brand?
Usually no. People respect founders who actively seek out and apply criticism to improve.
What kind of feedback should I ask for?
Ask for website feedback on clarity, trust, pricing, credibility, and the objection that would stop someone from signing up or buying.

Next step

Ready for honest feedback?

Prepare your post and brace for impact.